Systemic humiliation as daily social suffering

Daniel  Rothbart; Poul Poder

doi:10.1007/978-3-319-51391-1_2

Systemic humiliation as daily social suffering

Daniel Rothbart, Poul Poder

Abstract

In certain societies that promote extreme social inequalities, a group of dominant elites deploys instruments designed to control marginalized group members through propaganda, by diminishing their self-worth, and by instilling a sense of being unworthy of the respect (dignity) of others. These instruments may appear innocuous, as when civil-society leaders render “reasonable” decisions, government officials establish “essential” directives, and bureaucrats implement “common sense” policies. But their effect is to promote the collective suffering of marginalized people. In this chapter, we examine the dynamics of systemic humiliation through the use of five instruments: (1) laws that unjustly favor social elites, (2) an ideology of supremacy that rationalizes such laws, (3) a language that essentializes the degraded people, (4) images that reinforce such a status, and (5) symbols that in effect erase the achievements and capacities of these people. Drawing upon recent developments in social identity theory, moral philosophy, sociological theory, and clinical psychology, we argue that systemic humiliation generates social pain that is experienced as annulment of one’s inherent value; it is an affront to suffering persons’ moral selves. Mitigation of systemic humiliation is particularly challenging, as it operates without easily identifiable agents/humiliators. We conclude with preliminary recommendations regarding the need to adopt multiple perspectives to alleviate suffering caused by such humiliation.

Original language	English
Title of host publication	Alleviating World Suffering : The Challenge of Negative Quality of Life
Editors	Ronald E Anderson
Place of Publication	Springer International Publishing)
Publisher	Springer
Publication date	2017
Pages	35-48
Chapter	Part I, chapt. 2
ISBN (Print)	9783319513904
ISBN (Electronic)	9783319513911
DOIs	https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-51391-1_2
Publication status	Published - 2017

Series	Social Indicators Research
Volume	67
ISSN	0303-8300

Keywords

Faculty of Social Sciences
Humiliation
Power
Inequality
Social suffering
Elites
Mitigating humiliation

Access to Document

10.1007/978-3-319-51391-1_2

Cite this

Systemic humiliation as daily social suffering. / Rothbart, Daniel ; Poder, Poul.

Alleviating World Suffering: The Challenge of Negative Quality of Life. ed. / Ronald E Anderson. Springer International Publishing) : Springer, 2017. p. 35-48 (Social Indicators Research, Vol. 67).

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceeding › Book chapter › Research › peer-review

@inbook{c05ae95d11e34842a6e009b4fd71d61d,

title = "Systemic humiliation as daily social suffering",

abstract = "In certain societies that promote extreme social inequalities, a group of dominant elites deploys instruments designed to control marginalized group members through propaganda, by diminishing their self-worth, and by instilling a sense of being unworthy of the respect (dignity) of others. These instruments may appear innocuous, as when civil-society leaders render “reasonable” decisions, government officials establish “essential” directives, and bureaucrats implement “common sense” policies. But their effect is to promote the collective suffering of marginalized people. In this chapter, we examine the dynamics of systemic humiliation through the use of five instruments: (1) laws that unjustly favor social elites, (2) an ideology of supremacy that rationalizes such laws, (3) a language that essentializes the degraded people, (4) images that reinforce such a status, and (5) symbols that in effect erase the achievements and capacities of these people. Drawing upon recent developments in social identity theory, moral philosophy, sociological theory, and clinical psychology, we argue that systemic humiliation generates social pain that is experienced as annulment of one{\textquoteright}s inherent value; it is an affront to suffering persons{\textquoteright} moral selves. Mitigation of systemic humiliation is particularly challenging, as it operates without easily identifiable agents/humiliators. We conclude with preliminary recommendations regarding the need to adopt multiple perspectives to alleviate suffering caused by such humiliation.",

keywords = "Faculty of Social Sciences, Humiliation, Power, Inequality, Social suffering, Elites, Mitigating humiliation",

author = "Daniel Rothbart and Poul Poder",

year = "2017",

doi = "10.1007/978-3-319-51391-1_2",

language = "English",

isbn = " 9783319513904",

series = "Social Indicators Research",

publisher = "Springer",

pages = "35--48",

editor = "Anderson, {Ronald E}",

booktitle = "Alleviating World Suffering",

}

TY - CHAP

T1 - Systemic humiliation as daily social suffering

AU - Rothbart, Daniel

AU - Poder, Poul

PY - 2017

Y1 - 2017

N2 - In certain societies that promote extreme social inequalities, a group of dominant elites deploys instruments designed to control marginalized group members through propaganda, by diminishing their self-worth, and by instilling a sense of being unworthy of the respect (dignity) of others. These instruments may appear innocuous, as when civil-society leaders render “reasonable” decisions, government officials establish “essential” directives, and bureaucrats implement “common sense” policies. But their effect is to promote the collective suffering of marginalized people. In this chapter, we examine the dynamics of systemic humiliation through the use of five instruments: (1) laws that unjustly favor social elites, (2) an ideology of supremacy that rationalizes such laws, (3) a language that essentializes the degraded people, (4) images that reinforce such a status, and (5) symbols that in effect erase the achievements and capacities of these people. Drawing upon recent developments in social identity theory, moral philosophy, sociological theory, and clinical psychology, we argue that systemic humiliation generates social pain that is experienced as annulment of one’s inherent value; it is an affront to suffering persons’ moral selves. Mitigation of systemic humiliation is particularly challenging, as it operates without easily identifiable agents/humiliators. We conclude with preliminary recommendations regarding the need to adopt multiple perspectives to alleviate suffering caused by such humiliation.

AB - In certain societies that promote extreme social inequalities, a group of dominant elites deploys instruments designed to control marginalized group members through propaganda, by diminishing their self-worth, and by instilling a sense of being unworthy of the respect (dignity) of others. These instruments may appear innocuous, as when civil-society leaders render “reasonable” decisions, government officials establish “essential” directives, and bureaucrats implement “common sense” policies. But their effect is to promote the collective suffering of marginalized people. In this chapter, we examine the dynamics of systemic humiliation through the use of five instruments: (1) laws that unjustly favor social elites, (2) an ideology of supremacy that rationalizes such laws, (3) a language that essentializes the degraded people, (4) images that reinforce such a status, and (5) symbols that in effect erase the achievements and capacities of these people. Drawing upon recent developments in social identity theory, moral philosophy, sociological theory, and clinical psychology, we argue that systemic humiliation generates social pain that is experienced as annulment of one’s inherent value; it is an affront to suffering persons’ moral selves. Mitigation of systemic humiliation is particularly challenging, as it operates without easily identifiable agents/humiliators. We conclude with preliminary recommendations regarding the need to adopt multiple perspectives to alleviate suffering caused by such humiliation.

KW - Faculty of Social Sciences

KW - Humiliation

KW - Power

KW - Inequality

KW - Social suffering

KW - Elites

KW - Mitigating humiliation

U2 - 10.1007/978-3-319-51391-1_2

DO - 10.1007/978-3-319-51391-1_2

M3 - Book chapter

SN - 9783319513904

T3 - Social Indicators Research

SP - 35

EP - 48

BT - Alleviating World Suffering

A2 - Anderson, Ronald E

PB - Springer

CY - Springer International Publishing)

ER -