The value of pathogen information in treating clinical mastitis

Elva Cha; Rebecca L. Smith; Anders Ringgaard Kristensen; Julia A. Hertl; Ynte H. Schukken; Loren W. Tauer; Frank L. Welcome; Yrjö T. Gröhn

doi:10.1017/s0022029916000625

The value of pathogen information in treating clinical mastitis

Elva Cha, Rebecca L. Smith, Anders Ringgaard Kristensen, Julia A. Hertl, Ynte H. Schukken, Loren W. Tauer, Frank L. Welcome, Yrjö T. Gröhn

8 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The objective of this study was to determine the economic value of obtaining timely and more accurate clinical mastitis (CM) test results for optimal treatment of cows. Typically CM is first identified when the farmer observes recognisable outward signs. Further information of whether the pathogen causing CM is Gram-positive, Gram-negative or other (including no growth) can be determined by using on-farm culture methods. The most detailed level of information for mastitis diagnostics is obtainable by sending milk samples for culture to an external laboratory. Knowing the exact pathogen permits the treatment method to be specifically targeted to the causation pathogen, resulting in less discarded milk. The disadvantages are the additional waiting time to receive test results, which delays treating cows, and the cost of the culture test. Net returns per year (NR) for various levels of information were estimated using a dynamic programming model. The Value of Information (VOI) was then calculated as the difference in NR using a specific level of information as compared to more detailed information on the CM causative agent. The highest VOI was observed where the farmer assumed the pathogen causing CM was the one with the highest incidence in the herd and no pathogen specific CM information was obtained. The VOI of pathogen specific information, compared with non-optimal treatment of Staphylococcus aureus where recurrence and spread occurred due to lack of treatment efficacy, was $20.43 when the same incorrect treatment was applied to recurrent cases, and $30.52 when recurrent cases were assumed to be the next highest incidence pathogen and treated accordingly. This indicates that negative consequences associated with choosing the wrong CM treatment can make additional information cost-effective if pathogen identification is assessed at the generic information level and if the pathogen can spread to other cows if not treated appropriately.

Original language	English
Journal	Journal of Dairy Research
Volume	83
Issue number	4
Pages (from-to)	456-463
Number of pages	8
ISSN	0022-0299
DOIs	https://doi.org/10.1017/s0022029916000625
Publication status	Published - 1 Nov 2016

Access to Document

10.1017/s0022029916000625

Cite this

@article{5f56ad9c0b2e4d4d8c5966a294d6d5e6,

title = "The value of pathogen information in treating clinical mastitis",

abstract = "The objective of this study was to determine the economic value of obtaining timely and more accurate clinical mastitis (CM) test results for optimal treatment of cows. Typically CM is first identified when the farmer observes recognisable outward signs. Further information of whether the pathogen causing CM is Gram-positive, Gram-negative or other (including no growth) can be determined by using on-farm culture methods. The most detailed level of information for mastitis diagnostics is obtainable by sending milk samples for culture to an external laboratory. Knowing the exact pathogen permits the treatment method to be specifically targeted to the causation pathogen, resulting in less discarded milk. The disadvantages are the additional waiting time to receive test results, which delays treating cows, and the cost of the culture test. Net returns per year (NR) for various levels of information were estimated using a dynamic programming model. The Value of Information (VOI) was then calculated as the difference in NR using a specific level of information as compared to more detailed information on the CM causative agent. The highest VOI was observed where the farmer assumed the pathogen causing CM was the one with the highest incidence in the herd and no pathogen specific CM information was obtained. The VOI of pathogen specific information, compared with non-optimal treatment of Staphylococcus aureus where recurrence and spread occurred due to lack of treatment efficacy, was $20.43 when the same incorrect treatment was applied to recurrent cases, and $30.52 when recurrent cases were assumed to be the next highest incidence pathogen and treated accordingly. This indicates that negative consequences associated with choosing the wrong CM treatment can make additional information cost-effective if pathogen identification is assessed at the generic information level and if the pathogen can spread to other cows if not treated appropriately.",

author = "Elva Cha and Smith, {Rebecca L.} and Kristensen, {Anders Ringgaard} and Hertl, {Julia A.} and Schukken, {Ynte H.} and Tauer, {Loren W.} and Welcome, {Frank L.} and Gr{\"o}hn, {Yrj{\"o} T.}",

year = "2016",

month = nov,

day = "1",

doi = "10.1017/s0022029916000625",

language = "English",

volume = "83",

pages = "456--463",

journal = "Journal of Dairy Research",

issn = "0022-0299",

publisher = "Cambridge University Press",

number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The value of pathogen information in treating clinical mastitis

AU - Cha, Elva

AU - Smith, Rebecca L.

AU - Kristensen, Anders Ringgaard

AU - Hertl, Julia A.

AU - Schukken, Ynte H.

AU - Tauer, Loren W.

AU - Welcome, Frank L.

AU - Gröhn, Yrjö T.

PY - 2016/11/1

Y1 - 2016/11/1

N2 - The objective of this study was to determine the economic value of obtaining timely and more accurate clinical mastitis (CM) test results for optimal treatment of cows. Typically CM is first identified when the farmer observes recognisable outward signs. Further information of whether the pathogen causing CM is Gram-positive, Gram-negative or other (including no growth) can be determined by using on-farm culture methods. The most detailed level of information for mastitis diagnostics is obtainable by sending milk samples for culture to an external laboratory. Knowing the exact pathogen permits the treatment method to be specifically targeted to the causation pathogen, resulting in less discarded milk. The disadvantages are the additional waiting time to receive test results, which delays treating cows, and the cost of the culture test. Net returns per year (NR) for various levels of information were estimated using a dynamic programming model. The Value of Information (VOI) was then calculated as the difference in NR using a specific level of information as compared to more detailed information on the CM causative agent. The highest VOI was observed where the farmer assumed the pathogen causing CM was the one with the highest incidence in the herd and no pathogen specific CM information was obtained. The VOI of pathogen specific information, compared with non-optimal treatment of Staphylococcus aureus where recurrence and spread occurred due to lack of treatment efficacy, was $20.43 when the same incorrect treatment was applied to recurrent cases, and $30.52 when recurrent cases were assumed to be the next highest incidence pathogen and treated accordingly. This indicates that negative consequences associated with choosing the wrong CM treatment can make additional information cost-effective if pathogen identification is assessed at the generic information level and if the pathogen can spread to other cows if not treated appropriately.

AB - The objective of this study was to determine the economic value of obtaining timely and more accurate clinical mastitis (CM) test results for optimal treatment of cows. Typically CM is first identified when the farmer observes recognisable outward signs. Further information of whether the pathogen causing CM is Gram-positive, Gram-negative or other (including no growth) can be determined by using on-farm culture methods. The most detailed level of information for mastitis diagnostics is obtainable by sending milk samples for culture to an external laboratory. Knowing the exact pathogen permits the treatment method to be specifically targeted to the causation pathogen, resulting in less discarded milk. The disadvantages are the additional waiting time to receive test results, which delays treating cows, and the cost of the culture test. Net returns per year (NR) for various levels of information were estimated using a dynamic programming model. The Value of Information (VOI) was then calculated as the difference in NR using a specific level of information as compared to more detailed information on the CM causative agent. The highest VOI was observed where the farmer assumed the pathogen causing CM was the one with the highest incidence in the herd and no pathogen specific CM information was obtained. The VOI of pathogen specific information, compared with non-optimal treatment of Staphylococcus aureus where recurrence and spread occurred due to lack of treatment efficacy, was $20.43 when the same incorrect treatment was applied to recurrent cases, and $30.52 when recurrent cases were assumed to be the next highest incidence pathogen and treated accordingly. This indicates that negative consequences associated with choosing the wrong CM treatment can make additional information cost-effective if pathogen identification is assessed at the generic information level and if the pathogen can spread to other cows if not treated appropriately.

U2 - 10.1017/s0022029916000625

DO - 10.1017/s0022029916000625

M3 - Journal article

C2 - 27845019

SN - 0022-0299

VL - 83

SP - 456

EP - 463

JO - Journal of Dairy Research

JF - Journal of Dairy Research

IS - 4

ER -

The value of pathogen information in treating clinical mastitis

Abstract

Access to Document

Fingerprint

Cite this