The normativity of Hallin and Mancini’s work on media systems

TY - ABST

T1 - The normativity of Hallin and Mancini’s work on media systems

AU - Sükösd, Miklós Áron

N1 - The event was co-organized by the AFMK-Research Priority Areas ‘Media Systems: Media Policy, Regulation and Institutions’ and ‘Journalism Studies – Crossing Boundaries’ .

PY - 2016/1/20

Y1 - 2016/1/20

N2 - The normativity of Hallin and Mancini’s work on media systems Miklós Sukosd (Associate Professor, University of Copenhagen) Abstract This talk discusses comparative media system analysis focusing on Hallin and Mancini’s original work and their second (edited) book, Comparing Media Systems Beyond the Western World. On the one hand, I problematize the implicit normativity of Hallin and Mancini’s approach, and develop an argument regarding a normative position vs. a Weberian “sociology of understanding” approach to Western vs. other historical trajectories of media-politics relations. On the other hand, I examine the applicability of different elements of the Hallin and Mancini model for the analysis of authoritarian and semi-authoritarian media systems in Central and Eastern Europe (CEE) and other non-Western contexts. In these countries, key sectors of the media system remain under strong state control, or actually form a part of the state apparatus. Special attention is given to long-term factors such as reading culture and the level of general education (as indicated by high/low newspaper circulation) as well as censorship in a historical perspective. Finally, the recent shift towards more authoritarian media models in CEE and other parts of the world will be interpreted in the context of the effects of the global financial crisis in 2008, the emergence of the BRICS countries, and related problems of Western liberal democracies. Research seminar: Comparative Media Systems Revisited January 20-21 2016 Location: KUA/Southern Campus, room 22.0.49 Organizers: AFMK-Research Priority Areas ‘Media Systems: Media Policy, Regulation and Institutions’ and ‘Journalism Studies – Crossing Boundaries’ Henrik Søndergaard & Nete Nørgaard Kristensen Below you find the program and detailed information on our two-day research seminar to be held at KUA January 20-21 2016. The first day is devoted to the main-theme of the seminar, “Comparative Media Systems Revisited”, where four Nordic scholars will address important aspects of comparative media system analysis from various perspectives (for more detailed information see below). The second day members of the research priority areas will present their on-going research (see abstracts of all presentations below). Participants: Aske Kammer, SDU Emilie Taulø Jacobsen, UCPH Hallvard Moe, Bergen (day 1) Helle Strangaard, UCPH Henrik Søndergaard, UCPH Julie Lassen, UCPH Klaus Bruhn Jensen, UCPH (day 1) Ida Willig, RUC (day 1) Maria Bendix Olsen, RUC (day 1) Mark Ørsten, RUC (day 1) Mette Mortensen, UCPH Miklos Sukosd, UCPH Naimah Hussain, RUC (day 1) Nete Nørgaard Kristensen, UCPH Sofie Flensburg, UCPH Stig Hjarvard, UCPH Rasmus Helles, UCPH Program Research seminar: Comparative Media Systems Revisited January 20.-21. 2016, Location: KUA/Southern Campus, room 22.0.49 January 20 2016 13.00-17.00: Comparative Media Systems Revisited 13.00-13.15: Welcome and introduction (Henrik Søndergaard/Nete Nørgaard Kristensen) 13.15-14.00: Professor Hallvard Moe, University of Bergen: Why bother with a ”Nordic media mod-el”? 14.00-14.45: Professor Mark Blach-Ørsten, University of Roskilde: Media systems and media ethics 14.45-15.00: Coffee break 15.00-15.45: Stig Hjarvard: Intersections between media, culture and society 15.45-16.30: Miklos Sukosd: The normativity of Hallin and Mancini’s work on media systems 16.30-17.00: Summing up January 21 2016 09.00-09.45: Helle Strandgaard: As Culture Free As TV Can Be 09.45-10.30: Miklos Sukosd: Audience capital vs. power capital: The dynamic relationship of media and politics 10.30-10.45: Coffee Break 10.45-11.30: Sofie Flensburg: Danish media policy in the digital age 11.30-12.45: Aske Kammer: Subsidizing Media Innovation 12.45-13.30: Lunch 13.30-14.15: Julie Lassen: “DR: from broadcaster to multi-platform player” 14.15-15.00: Rasmus Helles: The OTT entertainment infrastructure: how winners take it all (again) 15.00-15.30: Summing up

AB - The normativity of Hallin and Mancini’s work on media systems Miklós Sukosd (Associate Professor, University of Copenhagen) Abstract This talk discusses comparative media system analysis focusing on Hallin and Mancini’s original work and their second (edited) book, Comparing Media Systems Beyond the Western World. On the one hand, I problematize the implicit normativity of Hallin and Mancini’s approach, and develop an argument regarding a normative position vs. a Weberian “sociology of understanding” approach to Western vs. other historical trajectories of media-politics relations. On the other hand, I examine the applicability of different elements of the Hallin and Mancini model for the analysis of authoritarian and semi-authoritarian media systems in Central and Eastern Europe (CEE) and other non-Western contexts. In these countries, key sectors of the media system remain under strong state control, or actually form a part of the state apparatus. Special attention is given to long-term factors such as reading culture and the level of general education (as indicated by high/low newspaper circulation) as well as censorship in a historical perspective. Finally, the recent shift towards more authoritarian media models in CEE and other parts of the world will be interpreted in the context of the effects of the global financial crisis in 2008, the emergence of the BRICS countries, and related problems of Western liberal democracies. Research seminar: Comparative Media Systems Revisited January 20-21 2016 Location: KUA/Southern Campus, room 22.0.49 Organizers: AFMK-Research Priority Areas ‘Media Systems: Media Policy, Regulation and Institutions’ and ‘Journalism Studies – Crossing Boundaries’ Henrik Søndergaard & Nete Nørgaard Kristensen Below you find the program and detailed information on our two-day research seminar to be held at KUA January 20-21 2016. The first day is devoted to the main-theme of the seminar, “Comparative Media Systems Revisited”, where four Nordic scholars will address important aspects of comparative media system analysis from various perspectives (for more detailed information see below). The second day members of the research priority areas will present their on-going research (see abstracts of all presentations below). Participants: Aske Kammer, SDU Emilie Taulø Jacobsen, UCPH Hallvard Moe, Bergen (day 1) Helle Strangaard, UCPH Henrik Søndergaard, UCPH Julie Lassen, UCPH Klaus Bruhn Jensen, UCPH (day 1) Ida Willig, RUC (day 1) Maria Bendix Olsen, RUC (day 1) Mark Ørsten, RUC (day 1) Mette Mortensen, UCPH Miklos Sukosd, UCPH Naimah Hussain, RUC (day 1) Nete Nørgaard Kristensen, UCPH Sofie Flensburg, UCPH Stig Hjarvard, UCPH Rasmus Helles, UCPH Program Research seminar: Comparative Media Systems Revisited January 20.-21. 2016, Location: KUA/Southern Campus, room 22.0.49 January 20 2016 13.00-17.00: Comparative Media Systems Revisited 13.00-13.15: Welcome and introduction (Henrik Søndergaard/Nete Nørgaard Kristensen) 13.15-14.00: Professor Hallvard Moe, University of Bergen: Why bother with a ”Nordic media mod-el”? 14.00-14.45: Professor Mark Blach-Ørsten, University of Roskilde: Media systems and media ethics 14.45-15.00: Coffee break 15.00-15.45: Stig Hjarvard: Intersections between media, culture and society 15.45-16.30: Miklos Sukosd: The normativity of Hallin and Mancini’s work on media systems 16.30-17.00: Summing up January 21 2016 09.00-09.45: Helle Strandgaard: As Culture Free As TV Can Be 09.45-10.30: Miklos Sukosd: Audience capital vs. power capital: The dynamic relationship of media and politics 10.30-10.45: Coffee Break 10.45-11.30: Sofie Flensburg: Danish media policy in the digital age 11.30-12.45: Aske Kammer: Subsidizing Media Innovation 12.45-13.30: Lunch 13.30-14.15: Julie Lassen: “DR: from broadcaster to multi-platform player” 14.15-15.00: Rasmus Helles: The OTT entertainment infrastructure: how winners take it all (again) 15.00-15.30: Summing up

M3 - Conference abstract for conference

T2 - "Comparative Media Systems Revisited"

Y2 - 20 January 2016 through 21 January 2016

ER -