No systematic effects of sampling direction on climate-growth relationships in a large-scale, multi-species tree-ring data set Dendrochronologia

Urs  Gut; Mátyás Árvai; Szymon Bijak; J. Julio Camarero; Anna Cedro; Roberto Cruz-García; Balázs Garamszegi; Andrew Hacket-Pain; Andrea Hevia; Weiwei Huang; Miriam Isaac-Renton; Ryszard  J.Kaczka; Marko Kazimirović; Wojciech Kędziora; Zoltán Kern; Marcin Klisz; Tomáš Kolář; Michael Körner; Veronica Kuznetsova; David Montwé; Any  Mary Petritan; Ion Catalin  Petritan; Lenka Plavcová; Romy Rehschuh; Eva Rocha; Michal Rybníček; Raúl Sánchez-Salguero; Jens Schröder; Niels Schwab; Branko Stajić; Robert Tomusiak; Martin Wilmking; Ute Sass-Klaassen; Allan Buras

doi:10.1016/j.dendro.2019.125624

No systematic effects of sampling direction on climate-growth relationships in a large-scale, multi-species tree-ring data set Dendrochronologia

Urs Gut^*, Mátyás Árvai, Szymon Bijak, J. Julio Camarero, Anna Cedro, Roberto Cruz-García, Balázs Garamszegi, Andrew Hacket-Pain, Andrea Hevia, Weiwei Huang, Miriam Isaac-Renton, Ryszard J.Kaczka, Marko Kazimirović, Wojciech Kędziora, Zoltán Kern, Marcin Klisz, Tomáš Kolář, Michael Körner, Veronica Kuznetsova, David MontwéAny Mary Petritan, Ion Catalin Petritan, Lenka Plavcová, Romy Rehschuh, Eva Rocha, Michal Rybníček, Raúl Sánchez-Salguero, Jens Schröder, Niels Schwab, Branko Stajić, Robert Tomusiak, Martin Wilmking, Ute Sass-Klaassen, Allan Buras

^*Corresponding author for this work

Forest, Nature and Biomass

7 Citations (Scopus)

17 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Ring-width series are important for diverse fields of research such as the study of past climate, forest ecology, forest genetics, and the determination of origin (dendro-provenancing) or dating of archaeological objects. Recent research suggests diverging climate-growth relationships in tree-rings due to the cardinal direction of extracting the tree cores (i.e. direction-specific effect). This presents an understudied source of bias that potentially affects many data sets in tree-ring research. In this study, we investigated possible direction-specific growth variability based on an international (10 countries), multi-species (8 species) tree-ring width network encompassing 22 sites. To estimate the effect of direction-specific growth variability on climate-growth relationships, we applied a combination of three methods: An analysis of signal strength differences, a Principal Component Gradient Analysis and a test on the direction-specific differences in correlations between indexed ring-widths series and climate variables. We found no evidence for systematic direction-specific effects on tree radial growth variability in high-pass filtered ring-width series. In addition, direction-specific growth showed only marginal effects on climate-growth correlations. These findings therefore indicate that there is no consistent bias caused by coring direction in data sets used for diverse dendrochronological applications on relatively mesic sites within forests in flat terrain, as were studied here. However, in extremely dry, warm or cold environments, or on steep slopes, and for different life-forms such as shrubs, further research is advisable.

Original language	English
Article number	125624
Journal	Dendrochronologia
Volume	57
Number of pages	9
ISSN	1125-7865
DOIs	https://doi.org/10.1016/j.dendro.2019.125624
Publication status	Published - Oct 2019

Access to Document

10.1016/j.dendro.2019.125624Licence: CC BY

No systematic effects of sampling direction on climate-growth relationships in a large-scale, multi-species tree-ring data setFinal published version, 5.23 MBLicence: CC BY

Cite this

Gut, U., Árvai, M., Bijak, S., Camarero, J. J., Cedro, A., Cruz-García, R., Garamszegi, B., Hacket-Pain, A., Hevia, A., Huang, W., Isaac-Renton, M., J.Kaczka, R., Kazimirović, M., Kędziora, W., Kern, Z., Klisz, M., Kolář, T., Körner, M., Kuznetsova, V., ... Buras, A. (2019). No systematic effects of sampling direction on climate-growth relationships in a large-scale, multi-species tree-ring data set Dendrochronologia. Dendrochronologia, 57, Article 125624. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.dendro.2019.125624

Gut, U, Árvai, M, Bijak, S, Camarero, JJ, Cedro, A, Cruz-García, R, Garamszegi, B, Hacket-Pain, A, Hevia, A, Huang, W, Isaac-Renton, M, J.Kaczka, R, Kazimirović, M, Kędziora, W, Kern, Z, Klisz, M, Kolář, T, Körner, M, Kuznetsova, V, Montwé, D, Mary Petritan, A, Petritan, IC, Plavcová, L, Rehschuh, R, Rocha, E, Rybníček, M, Sánchez-Salguero, R, Schröder, J, Schwab, N, Stajić, B, Tomusiak, R, Wilmking, M, Sass-Klaassen, U & Buras, A 2019, 'No systematic effects of sampling direction on climate-growth relationships in a large-scale, multi-species tree-ring data set Dendrochronologia', Dendrochronologia, vol. 57, 125624. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.dendro.2019.125624

@article{039bc98822bd472ea8550a1bc3fc4084,

title = "No systematic effects of sampling direction on climate-growth relationships in a large-scale, multi-species tree-ring data set Dendrochronologia",

abstract = "Ring-width series are important for diverse fields of research such as the study of past climate, forest ecology, forest genetics, and the determination of origin (dendro-provenancing) or dating of archaeological objects. Recent research suggests diverging climate-growth relationships in tree-rings due to the cardinal direction of extracting the tree cores (i.e. direction-specific effect). This presents an understudied source of bias that potentially affects many data sets in tree-ring research. In this study, we investigated possible direction-specific growth variability based on an international (10 countries), multi-species (8 species) tree-ring width network encompassing 22 sites. To estimate the effect of direction-specific growth variability on climate-growth relationships, we applied a combination of three methods: An analysis of signal strength differences, a Principal Component Gradient Analysis and a test on the direction-specific differences in correlations between indexed ring-widths series and climate variables. We found no evidence for systematic direction-specific effects on tree radial growth variability in high-pass filtered ring-width series. In addition, direction-specific growth showed only marginal effects on climate-growth correlations. These findings therefore indicate that there is no consistent bias caused by coring direction in data sets used for diverse dendrochronological applications on relatively mesic sites within forests in flat terrain, as were studied here. However, in extremely dry, warm or cold environments, or on steep slopes, and for different life-forms such as shrubs, further research is advisable.",

author = "Urs Gut and M{\'a}ty{\'a}s {\'A}rvai and Szymon Bijak and Camarero, {J. Julio} and Anna Cedro and Roberto Cruz-Garc{\'i}a and Bal{\'a}zs Garamszegi and Andrew Hacket-Pain and Andrea Hevia and Weiwei Huang and Miriam Isaac-Renton and Ryszard J.Kaczka and Marko Kazimirovi{\'c} and Wojciech K{\c e}dziora and Zolt{\'a}n Kern and Marcin Klisz and Tom{\'a}{\v s} Kol{\'a}{\v r} and Michael K{\"o}rner and Veronica Kuznetsova and David Montw{\'e} and {Mary Petritan}, Any and Petritan, {Ion Catalin} and Lenka Plavcov{\'a} and Romy Rehschuh and Eva Rocha and Michal Rybn{\'i}{\v c}ek and Ra{\'u}l S{\'a}nchez-Salguero and Jens Schr{\"o}der and Niels Schwab and Branko Staji{\'c} and Robert Tomusiak and Martin Wilmking and Ute Sass-Klaassen and Allan Buras",

year = "2019",

month = oct,

doi = "10.1016/j.dendro.2019.125624",

language = "English",

volume = "57",

journal = "Dendrochronologia",

issn = "1125-7865",

publisher = "Elsevier GmbH - Urban und Fischer",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - No systematic effects of sampling direction on climate-growth relationships in a large-scale, multi-species tree-ring data set Dendrochronologia

AU - Gut, Urs

AU - Árvai, Mátyás

AU - Bijak, Szymon

AU - Camarero, J. Julio

AU - Cedro, Anna

AU - Cruz-García, Roberto

AU - Garamszegi, Balázs

AU - Hacket-Pain, Andrew

AU - Hevia, Andrea

AU - Huang, Weiwei

AU - Isaac-Renton, Miriam

AU - J.Kaczka, Ryszard

AU - Kazimirović, Marko

AU - Kędziora, Wojciech

AU - Kern, Zoltán

AU - Klisz, Marcin

AU - Kolář, Tomáš

AU - Körner, Michael

AU - Kuznetsova, Veronica

AU - Montwé, David

AU - Mary Petritan, Any

AU - Petritan, Ion Catalin

AU - Plavcová, Lenka

AU - Rehschuh, Romy

AU - Rocha, Eva

AU - Rybníček, Michal

AU - Sánchez-Salguero, Raúl

AU - Schröder, Jens

AU - Schwab, Niels

AU - Stajić, Branko

AU - Tomusiak, Robert

AU - Wilmking, Martin

AU - Sass-Klaassen, Ute

AU - Buras, Allan

PY - 2019/10

Y1 - 2019/10

N2 - Ring-width series are important for diverse fields of research such as the study of past climate, forest ecology, forest genetics, and the determination of origin (dendro-provenancing) or dating of archaeological objects. Recent research suggests diverging climate-growth relationships in tree-rings due to the cardinal direction of extracting the tree cores (i.e. direction-specific effect). This presents an understudied source of bias that potentially affects many data sets in tree-ring research. In this study, we investigated possible direction-specific growth variability based on an international (10 countries), multi-species (8 species) tree-ring width network encompassing 22 sites. To estimate the effect of direction-specific growth variability on climate-growth relationships, we applied a combination of three methods: An analysis of signal strength differences, a Principal Component Gradient Analysis and a test on the direction-specific differences in correlations between indexed ring-widths series and climate variables. We found no evidence for systematic direction-specific effects on tree radial growth variability in high-pass filtered ring-width series. In addition, direction-specific growth showed only marginal effects on climate-growth correlations. These findings therefore indicate that there is no consistent bias caused by coring direction in data sets used for diverse dendrochronological applications on relatively mesic sites within forests in flat terrain, as were studied here. However, in extremely dry, warm or cold environments, or on steep slopes, and for different life-forms such as shrubs, further research is advisable.

AB - Ring-width series are important for diverse fields of research such as the study of past climate, forest ecology, forest genetics, and the determination of origin (dendro-provenancing) or dating of archaeological objects. Recent research suggests diverging climate-growth relationships in tree-rings due to the cardinal direction of extracting the tree cores (i.e. direction-specific effect). This presents an understudied source of bias that potentially affects many data sets in tree-ring research. In this study, we investigated possible direction-specific growth variability based on an international (10 countries), multi-species (8 species) tree-ring width network encompassing 22 sites. To estimate the effect of direction-specific growth variability on climate-growth relationships, we applied a combination of three methods: An analysis of signal strength differences, a Principal Component Gradient Analysis and a test on the direction-specific differences in correlations between indexed ring-widths series and climate variables. We found no evidence for systematic direction-specific effects on tree radial growth variability in high-pass filtered ring-width series. In addition, direction-specific growth showed only marginal effects on climate-growth correlations. These findings therefore indicate that there is no consistent bias caused by coring direction in data sets used for diverse dendrochronological applications on relatively mesic sites within forests in flat terrain, as were studied here. However, in extremely dry, warm or cold environments, or on steep slopes, and for different life-forms such as shrubs, further research is advisable.

U2 - 10.1016/j.dendro.2019.125624

DO - 10.1016/j.dendro.2019.125624

M3 - Journal article

SN - 1125-7865

VL - 57

JO - Dendrochronologia

JF - Dendrochronologia

M1 - 125624

ER -

No systematic effects of sampling direction on climate-growth relationships in a large-scale, multi-species tree-ring data set Dendrochronologia

Abstract

Access to Document

Fingerprint

Cite this