Effects of weed harrowing frequency on beneficial arthropods, plants and crop yield

Søren Navntoft; Kristian Kristensen; Ib Johnsen; Anne-Mette M. Jensen; Lene Sigsgaard; Peter Esbjerg

doi:10.1111/afe.12134

Effects of weed harrowing frequency on beneficial arthropods, plants and crop yield

Søren Navntoft, Kristian Kristensen, Ib Johnsen, Anne-Mette M. Jensen, Lene Sigsgaard, Peter Esbjerg

2 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

* Weed harrowing is an alternative to herbicides but it may have negative effects on epigaeic arthropods. We assessed the effects of frequent (four) versus two harrowings during the growing season on the density and diversity of generalist arthropods and the weed flora. Collection by flooding was used to estimate arthropod densities, after collection of weeds and crop for biomass estimation. * The predatory guild of spiders Tachyporus spp. carabids was reduced by frequent harrowing. Spiders and Tachyporus spp. were the most sensitive, with up to 38% higher density in plots harrowed only twice compared with four times. Furthermore, a marginally significant decrease in arthropod diversity was found after four harrowings. The negative effect of frequent harrowing on arthropods was probably caused by a combination of direct lethal effects and habitat disruption. Additional harrowings reduced weeds with weed seed biomass, on average, being 77% higher and species diversity being 48% higher in plots harrowed only twice compared with four times. There was a positive relationship between weed biomass and predatory arthropod guild density, supporting the hypothesis that weeds promote generalist arthropod predators. * Weed harrowing should be carried out early and limited to a minimum to protect flora and fauna. Frequent harrowing had no positive effect on yield, suggesting that more weeds can be tolerated to support biodiversity and biocontrol.

Original language	English
Journal	Agricultural and Forest Entomology
Volume	18
Issue number	1
Pages (from-to)	59-67
Number of pages	9
ISSN	1461-9563
DOIs	https://doi.org/10.1111/afe.12134
Publication status	Published - 1 Feb 2016

Access to Document

10.1111/afe.12134

Cite this

@article{6e0606d55db241afbb207bac410c0310,

title = "Effects of weed harrowing frequency on beneficial arthropods, plants and crop yield",

abstract = "* Weed harrowing is an alternative to herbicides but it may have negative effects on epigaeic arthropods. We assessed the effects of frequent (four) versus two harrowings during the growing season on the density and diversity of generalist arthropods and the weed flora. Collection by flooding was used to estimate arthropod densities, after collection of weeds and crop for biomass estimation. * The predatory guild of spiders Tachyporus spp. carabids was reduced by frequent harrowing. Spiders and Tachyporus spp. were the most sensitive, with up to 38% higher density in plots harrowed only twice compared with four times. Furthermore, a marginally significant decrease in arthropod diversity was found after four harrowings. The negative effect of frequent harrowing on arthropods was probably caused by a combination of direct lethal effects and habitat disruption. Additional harrowings reduced weeds with weed seed biomass, on average, being 77% higher and species diversity being 48% higher in plots harrowed only twice compared with four times. There was a positive relationship between weed biomass and predatory arthropod guild density, supporting the hypothesis that weeds promote generalist arthropod predators. * Weed harrowing should be carried out early and limited to a minimum to protect flora and fauna. Frequent harrowing had no positive effect on yield, suggesting that more weeds can be tolerated to support biodiversity and biocontrol.",

keywords = "Araneae, beneficial arthropods, Carabidae, mechanical weed control, organic farming, Staphylinidae, weed biomass, weed diversity, wheat",

author = "S{\o}ren Navntoft and Kristian Kristensen and Ib Johnsen and Jensen, {Anne-Mette M.} and Lene Sigsgaard and Peter Esbjerg",

year = "2016",

month = feb,

day = "1",

doi = "10.1111/afe.12134",

language = "English",

volume = "18",

pages = "59--67",

journal = "Agricultural and Forest Entomology",

issn = "1461-9563",

publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",

number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Effects of weed harrowing frequency on beneficial arthropods, plants and crop yield

AU - Navntoft, Søren

AU - Kristensen, Kristian

AU - Johnsen, Ib

AU - Jensen, Anne-Mette M.

AU - Sigsgaard, Lene

AU - Esbjerg, Peter

PY - 2016/2/1

Y1 - 2016/2/1

N2 - * Weed harrowing is an alternative to herbicides but it may have negative effects on epigaeic arthropods. We assessed the effects of frequent (four) versus two harrowings during the growing season on the density and diversity of generalist arthropods and the weed flora. Collection by flooding was used to estimate arthropod densities, after collection of weeds and crop for biomass estimation. * The predatory guild of spiders Tachyporus spp. carabids was reduced by frequent harrowing. Spiders and Tachyporus spp. were the most sensitive, with up to 38% higher density in plots harrowed only twice compared with four times. Furthermore, a marginally significant decrease in arthropod diversity was found after four harrowings. The negative effect of frequent harrowing on arthropods was probably caused by a combination of direct lethal effects and habitat disruption. Additional harrowings reduced weeds with weed seed biomass, on average, being 77% higher and species diversity being 48% higher in plots harrowed only twice compared with four times. There was a positive relationship between weed biomass and predatory arthropod guild density, supporting the hypothesis that weeds promote generalist arthropod predators. * Weed harrowing should be carried out early and limited to a minimum to protect flora and fauna. Frequent harrowing had no positive effect on yield, suggesting that more weeds can be tolerated to support biodiversity and biocontrol.

AB - * Weed harrowing is an alternative to herbicides but it may have negative effects on epigaeic arthropods. We assessed the effects of frequent (four) versus two harrowings during the growing season on the density and diversity of generalist arthropods and the weed flora. Collection by flooding was used to estimate arthropod densities, after collection of weeds and crop for biomass estimation. * The predatory guild of spiders Tachyporus spp. carabids was reduced by frequent harrowing. Spiders and Tachyporus spp. were the most sensitive, with up to 38% higher density in plots harrowed only twice compared with four times. Furthermore, a marginally significant decrease in arthropod diversity was found after four harrowings. The negative effect of frequent harrowing on arthropods was probably caused by a combination of direct lethal effects and habitat disruption. Additional harrowings reduced weeds with weed seed biomass, on average, being 77% higher and species diversity being 48% higher in plots harrowed only twice compared with four times. There was a positive relationship between weed biomass and predatory arthropod guild density, supporting the hypothesis that weeds promote generalist arthropod predators. * Weed harrowing should be carried out early and limited to a minimum to protect flora and fauna. Frequent harrowing had no positive effect on yield, suggesting that more weeds can be tolerated to support biodiversity and biocontrol.

KW - Araneae, beneficial arthropods, Carabidae, mechanical weed control, organic farming, Staphylinidae, weed biomass, weed diversity, wheat

U2 - 10.1111/afe.12134

DO - 10.1111/afe.12134

M3 - Journal article

SN - 1461-9563

VL - 18

SP - 59

EP - 67

JO - Agricultural and Forest Entomology

JF - Agricultural and Forest Entomology

IS - 1

ER -