Disentangling economic, cultural, and nutritional motives to identify entry points for regulating a wildlife commodity chain

Mona Estrella Bachmann; Jessica Junker; Roger Mundry; Martin Reinhardt Nielsen; Dagmar Haase; Heather Cohen; Joseph A.K. Kouassi; Hjalmar S. Kühl

doi:10.1016/j.biocon.2019.07.022

Disentangling economic, cultural, and nutritional motives to identify entry points for regulating a wildlife commodity chain

Mona Estrella Bachmann^*, Jessica Junker, Roger Mundry, Martin Reinhardt Nielsen, Dagmar Haase, Heather Cohen, Joseph A.K. Kouassi, Hjalmar S. Kühl

^*Corresponding author for this work

Section for Global Development

7 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Development of reduction policies for products risking the health or the environment usually begins with the question of whether the most promising entry point is reducing production, distribution or consumption. We aim to answer this crucial question for bushmeat, a wildlife product whose unsustainable harvest threatens biodiversity and food security. We collected one of the largest data sets available on bushmeat commodity chains by interviewing 348 hunters, 202 bushmeat traders, 190 restaurant owners, and 985 consumers in 47 urban and rural settlements around Taï National Park, Côte d'Ivoire. We examined 1) structural traits by network analyses and 2) disentangled the underlying economic, cultural, and nutritional motives for bushmeat utilization at the level of production (hunters), distribution (bushmeat traders), and consumption (households). We found that while economic drivers determined hunting, trading was associated with economic and cultural drivers and consumption was purely influenced by cultural habits. Bushmeat traders were promising candidates for effective regulation interventions, but held a small market share and the risk of displacement to other trading channels remains. Since cultural motives for consumption provide a key opportunity for large-scale behavioral changes, we propose consumers as the most effective point of entry for interventions. However, any such consumer level intervention should be supported by programs providing the remaining commodity chain actors with alternative livelihoods. Generally, interventions into the complex social-ecological system of wildlife commodity chains must consider interdependencies and require multi-actor approaches and monitoring to avoid displacement and diffusion effects and to guarantee a socially and ecologically sustainable change.

Original language	English
Article number	108177
Journal	Biological Conservation
Volume	238
Number of pages	12
ISSN	0006-3207
DOIs	https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biocon.2019.07.022
Publication status	Published - 2019

Keywords

Bushmeat
Conservation
Drivers
West Africa
Wildlife management
Wildlife trade

UN SDGs

This output contributes to the following UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)

Access to Document

10.1016/j.biocon.2019.07.022

Cite this

@article{ded17befeaed481b9027b02161d374de,

title = "Disentangling economic, cultural, and nutritional motives to identify entry points for regulating a wildlife commodity chain",

abstract = "Development of reduction policies for products risking the health or the environment usually begins with the question of whether the most promising entry point is reducing production, distribution or consumption. We aim to answer this crucial question for bushmeat, a wildlife product whose unsustainable harvest threatens biodiversity and food security. We collected one of the largest data sets available on bushmeat commodity chains by interviewing 348 hunters, 202 bushmeat traders, 190 restaurant owners, and 985 consumers in 47 urban and rural settlements around Ta{\"i} National Park, C{\^o}te d'Ivoire. We examined 1) structural traits by network analyses and 2) disentangled the underlying economic, cultural, and nutritional motives for bushmeat utilization at the level of production (hunters), distribution (bushmeat traders), and consumption (households). We found that while economic drivers determined hunting, trading was associated with economic and cultural drivers and consumption was purely influenced by cultural habits. Bushmeat traders were promising candidates for effective regulation interventions, but held a small market share and the risk of displacement to other trading channels remains. Since cultural motives for consumption provide a key opportunity for large-scale behavioral changes, we propose consumers as the most effective point of entry for interventions. However, any such consumer level intervention should be supported by programs providing the remaining commodity chain actors with alternative livelihoods. Generally, interventions into the complex social-ecological system of wildlife commodity chains must consider interdependencies and require multi-actor approaches and monitoring to avoid displacement and diffusion effects and to guarantee a socially and ecologically sustainable change.",

keywords = "Bushmeat, Conservation, Drivers, West Africa, Wildlife management, Wildlife trade",

author = "Bachmann, {Mona Estrella} and Jessica Junker and Roger Mundry and Nielsen, {Martin Reinhardt} and Dagmar Haase and Heather Cohen and Kouassi, {Joseph A.K.} and K{\"u}hl, {Hjalmar S.}",

year = "2019",

doi = "10.1016/j.biocon.2019.07.022",

language = "English",

volume = "238",

journal = "Biological Conservation",

issn = "0006-3207",

publisher = "Elsevier",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Disentangling economic, cultural, and nutritional motives to identify entry points for regulating a wildlife commodity chain

AU - Bachmann, Mona Estrella

AU - Junker, Jessica

AU - Mundry, Roger

AU - Nielsen, Martin Reinhardt

AU - Haase, Dagmar

AU - Cohen, Heather

AU - Kouassi, Joseph A.K.

AU - Kühl, Hjalmar S.

PY - 2019

Y1 - 2019

N2 - Development of reduction policies for products risking the health or the environment usually begins with the question of whether the most promising entry point is reducing production, distribution or consumption. We aim to answer this crucial question for bushmeat, a wildlife product whose unsustainable harvest threatens biodiversity and food security. We collected one of the largest data sets available on bushmeat commodity chains by interviewing 348 hunters, 202 bushmeat traders, 190 restaurant owners, and 985 consumers in 47 urban and rural settlements around Taï National Park, Côte d'Ivoire. We examined 1) structural traits by network analyses and 2) disentangled the underlying economic, cultural, and nutritional motives for bushmeat utilization at the level of production (hunters), distribution (bushmeat traders), and consumption (households). We found that while economic drivers determined hunting, trading was associated with economic and cultural drivers and consumption was purely influenced by cultural habits. Bushmeat traders were promising candidates for effective regulation interventions, but held a small market share and the risk of displacement to other trading channels remains. Since cultural motives for consumption provide a key opportunity for large-scale behavioral changes, we propose consumers as the most effective point of entry for interventions. However, any such consumer level intervention should be supported by programs providing the remaining commodity chain actors with alternative livelihoods. Generally, interventions into the complex social-ecological system of wildlife commodity chains must consider interdependencies and require multi-actor approaches and monitoring to avoid displacement and diffusion effects and to guarantee a socially and ecologically sustainable change.

AB - Development of reduction policies for products risking the health or the environment usually begins with the question of whether the most promising entry point is reducing production, distribution or consumption. We aim to answer this crucial question for bushmeat, a wildlife product whose unsustainable harvest threatens biodiversity and food security. We collected one of the largest data sets available on bushmeat commodity chains by interviewing 348 hunters, 202 bushmeat traders, 190 restaurant owners, and 985 consumers in 47 urban and rural settlements around Taï National Park, Côte d'Ivoire. We examined 1) structural traits by network analyses and 2) disentangled the underlying economic, cultural, and nutritional motives for bushmeat utilization at the level of production (hunters), distribution (bushmeat traders), and consumption (households). We found that while economic drivers determined hunting, trading was associated with economic and cultural drivers and consumption was purely influenced by cultural habits. Bushmeat traders were promising candidates for effective regulation interventions, but held a small market share and the risk of displacement to other trading channels remains. Since cultural motives for consumption provide a key opportunity for large-scale behavioral changes, we propose consumers as the most effective point of entry for interventions. However, any such consumer level intervention should be supported by programs providing the remaining commodity chain actors with alternative livelihoods. Generally, interventions into the complex social-ecological system of wildlife commodity chains must consider interdependencies and require multi-actor approaches and monitoring to avoid displacement and diffusion effects and to guarantee a socially and ecologically sustainable change.

KW - Bushmeat

KW - Conservation

KW - Drivers

KW - West Africa

KW - Wildlife management

KW - Wildlife trade

U2 - 10.1016/j.biocon.2019.07.022

DO - 10.1016/j.biocon.2019.07.022

M3 - Journal article

AN - SCOPUS:85071005283

SN - 0006-3207

VL - 238

JO - Biological Conservation

JF - Biological Conservation

M1 - 108177

ER -

Disentangling economic, cultural, and nutritional motives to identify entry points for regulating a wildlife commodity chain

Abstract

Keywords

UN SDGs

Access to Document

Fingerprint

Cite this