Using the Concept of Ethnicity in Defining Philistine Identity in the Iron Age

TY - JOUR

T1 - Using the Concept of Ethnicity in Defining Philistine Identity in the Iron Age

AU - Lemche, Niels Peter

PY - 2012/5/1

Y1 - 2012/5/1

N2 - Normally the discussion about Philistine identity vis-à-vis Isra-elite identity moves on a macro basis: On one side the Philistines, and on the other the Israelites. Little attention has been paid to the related concept of scale and social organization. If we try to find a background for the macro definitions: Israelites, Philistines, we move on an imaginary level. It is a kind of literary concept nourished among the elitenever more than a few percent of any ancient society. The realities of ancient Palestine in the Iron Age were different. First of all nationality was an unknown concept, and any idea of ethnicity related to the issue of nationality (as in Avraham Faust's recent book on Israelite origins) is irrelevant. Second, there were, as argued by, among others Mario Liverani, no national borders in Antiquity. Borders were fiscal delimitations: Who paid tax to whom? Third, ethnicity follows the group, and a certain person may change identity as he moves through differ-ent groups. In a society of such small extent as ancient Palestine, each villager would have an identity defined by his village as against the members of the neighboring communityethnicity cannot be separated from identityand villagers living in one area will have a distinct consciousness of being differ-ent from those who live on the other side of the river. National identity, when the idea of ethnicity includes all people living within the fiscal borders of an ancient state, would hardly ever be called upon, except when the elite wanted to defend its privilegesits right to obtain taxesagainst intruders. Thus the concept of a PhilistineIsraelite controversy based on different ide-as about ethnicity is no more than a projection of modern ideas about the na-tional state which came into being two hundred years ago.

AB - Normally the discussion about Philistine identity vis-à-vis Isra-elite identity moves on a macro basis: On one side the Philistines, and on the other the Israelites. Little attention has been paid to the related concept of scale and social organization. If we try to find a background for the macro definitions: Israelites, Philistines, we move on an imaginary level. It is a kind of literary concept nourished among the elitenever more than a few percent of any ancient society. The realities of ancient Palestine in the Iron Age were different. First of all nationality was an unknown concept, and any idea of ethnicity related to the issue of nationality (as in Avraham Faust's recent book on Israelite origins) is irrelevant. Second, there were, as argued by, among others Mario Liverani, no national borders in Antiquity. Borders were fiscal delimitations: Who paid tax to whom? Third, ethnicity follows the group, and a certain person may change identity as he moves through differ-ent groups. In a society of such small extent as ancient Palestine, each villager would have an identity defined by his village as against the members of the neighboring communityethnicity cannot be separated from identityand villagers living in one area will have a distinct consciousness of being differ-ent from those who live on the other side of the river. National identity, when the idea of ethnicity includes all people living within the fiscal borders of an ancient state, would hardly ever be called upon, except when the elite wanted to defend its privilegesits right to obtain taxesagainst intruders. Thus the concept of a PhilistineIsraelite controversy based on different ide-as about ethnicity is no more than a projection of modern ideas about the na-tional state which came into being two hundred years ago.

KW - Faculty of Theology

KW - Det Gamle Testamente

KW - Etnicitet

KW - Filisterne

M3 - Journal article

SN - 0901-8328

VL - 26

SP - 12

EP - 29

JO - Scandinavian Journal of the Old Testament

JF - Scandinavian Journal of the Old Testament

IS - 1

ER -