On the integrated cognitive theory for information retrieval: Drifting outside the cave of the laboratory framework

Peter Ingwersen; Kalervo Järvelin

On the integrated cognitive theory for information retrieval: Drifting outside the cave of the laboratory framework

Peter Ingwersen, Kalervo Järvelin

Department of Communication

Abstract

The paper demonstrates how the Laboratory Research Framework fits into the holistic Cognitive Framework for IR. It first discusses the Laboratory Framework with emphasis on its underlying assumptions and known limitations. This is followed by a view of interaction and relevance phenomena associated with IR evaluation and central to the understanding of IR. The ensuing section outlines how interactive IR is viewed from a Cognitive Framework, and ‘light' interactive IR experiments are suggested performed by drawing on the latter framework's contextual possibilities. These include independent variables drawn from a collection, matching principles in a retrieval system, and the searcher's situation and task context. The paper ends with concluding points of summarization of issues encountered.

Original language	English
Journal	Cuadernos de Relaciones Laborales
Volume	18
Pages (from-to)	381-402
Number of pages	22
ISSN	1131-8635
Publication status	Published - 2008

Keywords

Integrated Cognitive Framework for IR
Laboratory framework for IR
IR interaction
IR interaction light
Experimental design

Cite this

@article{971afba4315749bc8fb598e9891d6553,

title = "On the integrated cognitive theory for information retrieval: Drifting outside the cave of the laboratory framework",

abstract = "The paper demonstrates how the Laboratory Research Framework fits into the holistic Cognitive Framework for IR. It first discusses the Laboratory Framework with emphasis on its underlying assumptions and known limitations. This is followed by a view of interaction and relevance phenomena associated with IR evaluation and central to the understanding of IR. The ensuing section outlines how interactive IR is viewed from a Cognitive Framework, and {\textquoteleft}light' interactive IR experiments are suggested performed by drawing on the latter framework's contextual possibilities. These include independent variables drawn from a collection, matching principles in a retrieval system, and the searcher's situation and task context. The paper ends with concluding points of summarization of issues encountered. ",

keywords = "Kognitiv IR teori, Laboratoriemodel for IR, Interaktiv informationss{\o}gning, Eksperimentel design, Integrated Cognitive Framework for IR, Laboratory framework for IR, IR interaction, IR interaction light, Experimental design",

author = "Peter Ingwersen and Kalervo J{\"a}rvelin",

note = "Reprint of 'On the holistic cognitive theory for information retrieval', published in Dominic, S & Kiss, F (eds.) Studies in Theory of Information Retrieval, Budapest: Foundation for Information Society, 2007: 135-147.",

year = "2008",

language = "English",

volume = "18",

pages = "381--402",

journal = "Cuadernos de Relaciones Laborales",

issn = "1131-8635",

publisher = "Universidad Complutense de Madrid * Servicio de Publicaciones",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - On the integrated cognitive theory for information retrieval

T2 - Drifting outside the cave of the laboratory framework

AU - Ingwersen, Peter

AU - Järvelin, Kalervo

N1 - Reprint of 'On the holistic cognitive theory for information retrieval', published in Dominic, S & Kiss, F (eds.) Studies in Theory of Information Retrieval, Budapest: Foundation for Information Society, 2007: 135-147.

PY - 2008

Y1 - 2008

N2 - The paper demonstrates how the Laboratory Research Framework fits into the holistic Cognitive Framework for IR. It first discusses the Laboratory Framework with emphasis on its underlying assumptions and known limitations. This is followed by a view of interaction and relevance phenomena associated with IR evaluation and central to the understanding of IR. The ensuing section outlines how interactive IR is viewed from a Cognitive Framework, and ‘light' interactive IR experiments are suggested performed by drawing on the latter framework's contextual possibilities. These include independent variables drawn from a collection, matching principles in a retrieval system, and the searcher's situation and task context. The paper ends with concluding points of summarization of issues encountered.

AB - The paper demonstrates how the Laboratory Research Framework fits into the holistic Cognitive Framework for IR. It first discusses the Laboratory Framework with emphasis on its underlying assumptions and known limitations. This is followed by a view of interaction and relevance phenomena associated with IR evaluation and central to the understanding of IR. The ensuing section outlines how interactive IR is viewed from a Cognitive Framework, and ‘light' interactive IR experiments are suggested performed by drawing on the latter framework's contextual possibilities. These include independent variables drawn from a collection, matching principles in a retrieval system, and the searcher's situation and task context. The paper ends with concluding points of summarization of issues encountered.

KW - Kognitiv IR teori

KW - Laboratoriemodel for IR

KW - Interaktiv informationssøgning

KW - Eksperimentel design

KW - Integrated Cognitive Framework for IR

KW - Laboratory framework for IR

KW - IR interaction

KW - IR interaction light

KW - Experimental design

M3 - Journal article

SN - 1131-8635

VL - 18

SP - 381

EP - 402

JO - Cuadernos de Relaciones Laborales

JF - Cuadernos de Relaciones Laborales

ER -

On the integrated cognitive theory for information retrieval: Drifting outside the cave of the laboratory framework

Abstract

Keywords

Fingerprint

Cite this